I'll try to get to the chase with this... But there are these two guys I like, they're both a year or so older than me. One I've had a crush on for a while, but he's a huge goofball. Okay a huge adorable goofball. The other one is a bit more of the serious, mature sexy type. I've known him for a while longer but my heart is dumb and indecisive.
Then quit being superficial. Make a genuine connection with one or the other. You're only indecisive because you allow yourself to be. I've been in a similar situation and it comes down to who you feel a closer connection with.