>>21To be fair, a lot of it is generic ambient shoegaze jam bands, just as a lot of any genre is generic music of their respective genre. I personally never cared much for EITS either; I always thought they were super dull and overrated. Never listened to God is an Astronaut. You can kind of tell which bands are just generic whatever and which put more into their songwriting and production that make it more unique and well-written. Bands like...GY!BE.
as far as GY!BE goes, I'd say personally rank their releases as:
Slow Riot... >
F#A#∞ >
Lift Your Skinny Fists... >
Allelujah!... >>>>>>>>
Yanqui U.X.O. =
Asunder, Sweet... >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> most other post-rock
While some people dislike
Slow Riot for its conciseness, I find all other GY!BE has moments where there's just not anything really happening, either because they're lost in the drone that doesn't exactly hook the listener, or because the compositions are too long for their own good. That's not to say they're bad - hell, even
Asunder, Sweet... is like a 7/10 imo. But
Slow Riot is just perfection. I'd recommend you start there with GY!BE. It's where I did, and I don't regret it.
I also think you'd like MONO's two golden albums
You Are There and
Hymn to the Immortal Wind. The latter is a concept album with an accompanying written story, and both are extremely intimate, cinematic, and downright impressive records. Whereas most post-rock is either too polished or too lo-fi/jammy, both of these were produced by Steve Albini, who found an amazing middle ground. They're just incredible, and the songwriting is hnnnnnnng. But I digress, this is the GY!BE thread, not a MONO thread (which we don't have and I'll probably make soon).
my point is start with
Slow Riot and not the newest record.
also
>>20 u fkn dum m8