>>7 Looking at the cas latency of the new sticks, it's 9. Not sure what the other stick is since I can't remember exactly what stick it is. And after looking through Newegg, the two most likely candidates for what my older stick is(Which is still installed by the way. It's a single 8GB stick.) either run at 8 or 9 cas latency.
Either way, I'm thinking I'm going to replace that single stick next chance I get. And while I'm at it I might as well replace the mobo, power supply, and CPU. Unlike most people who can live with parts that are years old, I'm uncomfortable having aging parts. I may not upgrade every year, but three is my limit I think.