This reply is over 1000 words. Fun.
>>22 Can't tell if your first two sentences are sarcastic or not.
Look, Muslims are
not a homogenous group, and the only example I can think of that probably enforce all of the rules you bring up are countries like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Yemen, and other oppressive, third world countries that are ruled by corrupt governments whose leaders are arrogant, over-privileged pigs. In those cases, Islam isn't a religion so much as it is a tool of oppression.
In any case, nothing is black and white, and these are my thoughts on each of them.
Too orthodoxToo vague. Assuming you mean what I think you do, there are plenty of moderate and barely practicing Muslims out there. Not quite in the way that there are Christians, but they exist.
Too many rules, and violent reinforcements of said rulesSubjective. I'd say that violent reinforcement of religious rules is more a symptom of a culture and how they interpret religious scripture than the religion itself, And most Muslim nations are severely developed compared to Western nations. Some might even say because of them. and although there are verses in the Quran that seemingly justify violence in certain circumstances, there are just as many that speak against it.
This doesn't quite account for Islamic terrorism in the West, though. Like I said above, it's all subjective.
Any public joke about the prophet or whatever is usually paid with bloodAs far as the offense taken at these kinds of jokes, I'd attribute this to cultural differences as well. I think a lot of where Islam and the West come into conflict is in regards to how each society has developed, and, well, in their society joking about the Prophet is just something you don't do. Western nations have been secular long enough to develop a sense of humour in regards to religious, Muslim societies not so much. They don't see the humour in a joke about their Prophet, all they see is disrespect. I suppose in a simplified sense, you've insulted their honour, and they need some kind of reparation for that. Like I said, their societies just stopped developing after a point.
Still, the violent response is still totally unjustified and has no place in this day and age, and more Muslims should learn to just chill. I totally agree with you here.
Once you're born in a muslim family, it's too hard to change religionWell, that depends on the family dynamic, country and social atmosphere, doesn't it? I was born into a Muslim family, and although I went through a bit of an atheist phase in high school, I can't say that I've ever considered changing my religion. Not that I don't think that it happens, it's just that I think most Muslims know - or basically, it's one of our beliefs - that Islam is basically just the last fully formed Abrahamic religion, and the Jewish and Christian revelations are considered to be religious canon that's been corrupted over time. So yeah, this means that the Torah and the Bible are considered to have originally been the word of Allah.
I think that most historical scholars would agree that what Muslims consider to be older prophets and revelatory texts are basically the same as well. And with that in mind, I can't really see many people "going back," if you get my meaning. I suppose there's that air of lessened restrictions (I don't think Jews have to be be devout at all, they're judged by God based on, like, something else) that the other Abrahamic religions offer, but even so if a Muslim were to abandon Islam I feel like they'd probably lean more towards atheism.
Mosque broadcast using megaphone every 4.305 times a day, really, and it's not nearly as intrusive as it sounds. My family in Pakistan lives right behind a Mosque, so we get the full brunt of it, and aside from my Dad wanting us to turn down the volume on the T.V. to listen, it's nothing more than a friendly reminder that you probably should pray soon. You know, if you're a good Muslim. It's not like they install speakers and camera's inside of your house and force you to pray at gunpoint, it's just a harmless call to prayer.
Dunno what it's like in Arab countries, but when I was in Dubai I never heard the Adhan once. Probably because of all the tourists, but yeah. They only broadcast it from Mosques.
Expecting other people to just comply with their needs due to religious reasons, even when it would in turn be inconvenient to other people
Examples? Unless it's a really pressing need, I'd say anyone who does this is just a precious, touchy idiot. There are some Muslims who like to flaunt their religious knowledge and adherence purely because it makes them superior, and those people are just arrogant assholes.
Deny any wrongdoings of Islam. Yes it's not exclusive to Islam, but that doesn't mean you can deny it ever exists.
This is a bit vague as well. If you're talking about terrorism and, to a lesser degress historical conquests, then there may be an element of defensiveness in that. In regards to terrorism, whenever a criminal is a Muslim, the media and the public like to up-play that fact, and of course Muslims start to feel attacked. It makes them look bad, and most of the time they don't really have a decent platform on which to defend themselves. You see the same thing happen with other groups of people, the most obvious example to me being African American people.
And then you have some bigoted or misinformed people who see some of the things that Muslims supposedly do and blame it on the religion as a whole. It's a common perception in the West that Muslim women are oppressed, and while this may be the case where there's a domineering family or husband or a generally oppressive environment, in my experience this is... subjective. There are restrictions on women in Islam, or perceived restrictions probably born of a traditional patriarchal skew, but Muslim feminism is definitely a thing, and if those countries were in any state in which free speech or thought was a thing, I'm sure it'd catch on. Hell, it was going alright in Iran before the Islamic Revo... okay, that's a bad example.
Whatever. In Pakistan I'd go to malls and see young women with long hair wearing jeans and t-shirts, so it's not like everyone's forced to wear a niqab.
On a broader level, though, I've met full on academic Muslims who will have a full-on philosophical discussion with you in regards to Islamic conduct, beliefs, Quranic verses and their meanings etc. You could tell them your problems with Islam, and they'd listen and give you a clear, succinct rebuttal without getting heated. It's not like Islam is so written in stone that any dissenting opinion or thought is immediately squashed.
Limiting inflow of information. Anime and manga are censored. My BL....
Well, rich, oppressive governments gotta oppress their people somehow.
And anything complaining about the government's is immediately invalid. Most Muslim governments are fragile, poor and/or corrupt.
Well, ending this ridiculously long, biased, and probably grammatically incorrect not-rant that probably didn't address anything to a sufficient degree but sums up my opinions and concessions pretty well - I think there are problems with Islam and Muslim nations as well. But I also think there's a right way to interpret the religion, and that finding that right way is the whole point to being a Muslim.
It's like, too hard to have an all-bases-covered opinion on this, man. But in any case, I still think they should let refugees in. The alternative is too painful.