Overrated game for me is definitely Five Nights At Freddy's. It's not scary! It even won numerous awards because of the alleged scare factor! The animatronics won't scare the heck out of you. I even recognized one of them; the running type -- Crash Bandicoot! So how am I going to be frightened? It was rated as high as 10 out of 10. Wow..

As for underrated game, I think its gonna be Silent Hill Downpour; insofar as IGN rating's of 4.5 out 10 is concerned.