Hey thanks for the thread Yatahaze!
I'm a huge fan of O'Malley's work and gobbled seconds up within the day it was placed into my hands. I agree with you, it isn't an overly original premise, the idea of a multiple universe story arch has been tackled before. Jeff Smith the famous author of the
Bone series also created a graphic novel called
Rasl. In my opinion, the multiple universe story line was more part of the plot, and in Seconds exception, explained rather well. I would suggest it if you enjoyed the themes presented in Seconds. Not to say Seconds was a bad story, I loved it, although not nearly as much as Scott Pilgrim.
I find O'Malley writes very personally and within his age group. Scott was 24-ish(don't quote me) at the time and O'Malley was too (probably); I have a feeling a lot of Scott's character was portrayed through O'Malley. This is also true in Seconds as well, the character Katie is in about her early thirty's, much like O'Malley at the time, including a lot of issues and emotions that O'Malley must have felt. Katie as a character is likeable and hate-able in perfect O'Malley fashion, but the emotions and actions/reactions seemed only skin deep. I could tell there was a lot of Brian O'Malley in Katie's character.
Aside from that as you have mentioned, the artwork is fantastic, the warm colors giving life and excitement in times of action. However contrasting with O'Malleys choice of not cool, but
dark colours in times of romance, plot, or conflict. This creates a wonderful tone and plays with one of his themes of internal fear, or the unknowing. \/ - more!
O'Malley has created a wonderful piece, I congratulate him not only for making a great story, but also for successfully creating a followup to a series that helped
define a genre. I'm so happy that O'Malley created seconds and crafted it well, it proves that he can still work, and create great narratives and art.
TT;DR This was a wonderful followup to the Scott Pilgrim series; when the dust settles I can't wait to see what O'Malley makes next!