So, I'm going to start doing commissions and I want to do $10 gift card/codes as payment (I'm not doing Paypal because reasons), and I'll draw anything as long as it's not NSFW and/or Furries- and that's only because I can't draw them, not because I don't like it.

Anyways, my main question is, is $10 too much to ask for?

I'd say that as a minimum fee, $10 is very fair (assuming, of course, that you are reasonably skilled), however, you many want to increase the price occasionally based on the complexity of the piece.